Friday, July 31, 2026

Since when was the hijab a feminist statement?

June 30, 2015 by  
Filed under Choosing Lingerie

Comments Off

Over ten years ago, the satirical American magazine the Onion published an article under the headline: Women Now Empowered By Everything A Woman Does. If you’ve ever heard someone insist that pole dancing is empowering, the Onion predicted it. In a take-down of the lazy gluttony of ‘choice-feminism’, it told us: ‘Whereas early feminists campaigned tirelessly for improved health care and safe, legal access to abortion, often against a backdrop of public indifference or hostility, today’s feminist asserts control over her biological destiny by wearing a baby-doll T-shirt with the word “Hoochie” spelled in glitter.’

I thought I was reading the Onion all over again yesterday, when I stumbled across the Guardian’s latest viral video: ‘My hijab has nothing to do with oppression. It’s a feminist statement’. Against a backdrop of lingerie models, bikini babes, and sad western women weighing themselves (still in lingerie), hijab-wearer Hanna Yusuf adopts her primary school teacher voice and asks us, very, very slowly ‘in a world when a woman’s value is often reduced to her sexual allure, what could be more empowering than rejecting that notion?’ Western women, we discover, are dopes to consumerism, brainwashed into buying more diets, thongs and trashy magazines. The hijabi wearer, in covering her lust-inducing hair, is truly free. There are even background ‘gasps’ to represent the shocked non-Muslim viewer discovering this concept for the first time! HUH?!

Well, Hanna, let me tell you something. I’ve never once worn a bikini in my life. Like you, I don’t fancy being sexualised on my family beach holiday, and I do a dab hand in 1950s swimsuits: practical, glamorous, and comfortable around my Dad. During my long, ultra-feminist years of refusal to shave my legs, I endured annual struggles with billowing cover-ups and clingy leggings (though last time I went to a theology lecture, sensitive depilation was as mandated by most branches of Islam as it is by Cosmopolitan). I’m a conservative woman at heart: I don’t even practice sex before marriage. Not because I’m a female eunuch, but because I, like many Muslims, believe that sex is sacred.

But, Hanna, I don’t need a hijab to dress like a feminist. And your choice between veil or bikini is a false dichotomy. In fact, it’s one of the oldest anti-feminist tropes in the book, a mild reframing of the old Madonna-whore complex, for which my own Christianity has been rightly pilloried. Feminists are building a future in which the female body is no more a fetish object than the male: where I can eschew the bikini, but feel the wind through my Chelsea blow-dry, and still be valued more for my understanding of 16th century history than for how I look in either. Granted, we’re not there yet. But the more we treat parts of our bodies as sexual triggers and hide them away, the more we sexualise them in the male imagination. Both Islamic dress codes and Hollywood magazines sustain themselves by policing women’s bodies.

Hanna, I don’t think the hijab is about ‘oppression’ – not, as you say, in modern Britain. After all, you’re getting a Guardian vox-pop out of it. And obviously, as a liberal, I’d oppose any attempt to ban it. But while you rightly point out that most Western women are psychologically enslaved to diet culture, is it unreasonable to suggest to a student of Marx that false consciousness – remember that? – applies as much to women in hijabis as women in bikinis? I’m not sure I’ve ever met a woman, in a hijab, bikini or knee-length skirt, who makes culturally free choices about her wardrobe.



And why am I, a white woman, commenting in turn on what a Muslim woman wears? Because I’m also writing about my own cultural history. The attitudes to female modesty proposed in videos like this run through every poem I read for my academic work on women in the sixteenth century: Christian men justifying rape, because a woman accidentally flashed an ankle in their direction. My great-grandmothers, and great-great-grandmothers, fought to escape the limits of modesty policing. To quietly accept such premises all over again is to make a mockery of their entire struggle.

The hijab, by definition, highlights sexual difference and effaces intersexuality. As the Harvard academic Leila Ahmed details in her book, A Quiet Revolution, the rapid resurgence of the veil in the modern Muslim world has not been matched by a renewed dedication to men’s Islamic dress codes: women are required to display their belonging to the clan group, while men are not. As one ex-Muslim also told the Guardian, it allows women to be policed by Muslim strangers:

You’re much more visible as a woman. You’re conditioned to behave in a certain way with a headscarf. I mean, you’re not going to go to a pub with a headscarf, are you? You’re not going to stay out late with a headscarf. It’s a form of control.

There’s a simple question I ask of religious prohibitions, whether it’s Christian men telling me I couldn’t be a bishop, or the Haredi Jewish women hiding themselves away from the world during their menstrual cycles. Does God ban men from doing it, too? If not, there’s nothing feminist about it.

Tags: A Quiet Revolution, Feminism, Guardian, Hanna Yusuf, Hijab, Islam, Leila Ahmed, Muslims, Sex

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

Lucy Mecklenburgh poses in purple lingerie set as she shows off her sculpted …

June 30, 2015 by  
Filed under Lingerie Events

Comments Off

Fehintola Betiku for MailOnline

32

View
comments

It’s no secret that she is a fitness fanatic.

So taking to Instagram to show off the results of her workout regime, Lucy Mecklenburgh posted an ab-tastic photograph on Monday.

As well as flaunting her sculpted stomach, the 23-year-old also raised the temperature as she posed in a plunging purple lingerie set.

Scroll Down For Video 

If you got it, flaunt it: Lucy Mecklenburgh posed in purple underwear as she showed off the results of her fitness regime with an Instagram selfie on Monday

Standing opposite a mirror for the snap, Lucy looked amazing in the Calvin Klein set made up of a bralet and briefs. 

Using the picture to promote her fitness and health brand, Results With Lucy, the former TOWIE star proved that self promotion is indeed the best type of advertising.

She wrote alongside the image: ‘New @calvinklein undies Be proud of your #RealResults’.

Secret to her results? The 23-year-old also shared a picture of a meal she had with boyfriend Louis Smith

Currently dating Louis Smith, Lucy also shared a picture of Sunday dinner as she enjoyed another date night with the Olympic champion.

Clearly in awe of one another, the couple recently joined concert goers at London’s O2 Arena at the John Legend show on Thursday.

Looking the part for their evening, the gym enthusiast stunned vibrant in a peach dress comprised of a fitted, sleeveless bodice and loose fitting pleated skirt.  

‘Watching John Legend’: Mecklenburgh enjoyed a night out with her beau at The O2 on Thursday

Meanwhile gymnast Louis, 26, sported a raffish wide-brimmed black hat over his smart blazer, whites shirt and jeans combination. 

Ahead of the concert, the couple, who have been dating since last December, were hand in hand as they made their way to Canary Wharf restaurant Roka.

Once at the show, Lucy gifted her fans with a picture of her and Louis as they overlooked the arena, the caption on the snap read: ‘Watching John Legend at the O2 with @louissmith1989 #O2Arena’. 

Hand in hand: The couple, who have been an item since December, cut a cute figure as they journeyed along

Comments (32)

Share what you think

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Who is this week’s top commenter?
Find out now

Share and Enjoy